Super Lawyers
Justia Lawyer Rating for Ronald V. Miller Jr.
Best Law Firms
Avvo Rating - 10
Million Dollar Advocates Forum
Litigator Awards

Property Damage Claim Problems and Solutions

As personal injury lawyers, we often assist our injured clients with the aftermath of auto accidents, including dealing with property damage claims and arranging rental cars, all at no charge as a courtesy. However, most auto accidents do not result in physical injuries, and many people find themselves navigating these claims without legal assistance. This can sometimes lead to insurance companies taking advantage of accident victims in property damage cases.

This guide aims to address common problems and help accident victims protect their rights. Its advice is based on Maryland law but applicable in many other jurisdictions.

  • Who is responsible for paying my property damage? A look at the scenarios and how to maximize how much you get and how fast you get it.

Solving Property Damage Claim Problems

These are the ten most common problems victims have with car accident property damage claims and what the solution to the problem is.

The accident was their fault. Why can’t I get a rental car?

This is a common source of frustration. You know the accident wasn’t your fault, but the other driver’s insurance company won’t “accept liability” and put you into a rental car. This is usually because the carrier has not been able to contact their insured driver to obtain their version of the accident.

The insurance company has a contractual obligation to their insured to investigate before paying benefits. Normally this entails getting their driver’s version of events, even in clear liability collisions. The best way to get around this is to get a rental under your own collision coverage policy if it is covered, or to pay out of pocket for a rental and get reimbursed once liability is accepted. Of course, most of you reading this are getting the “get rental insurance” advice a little late.

The insurance company won’t pay enough to pay off my loan. What can I do?

Maryland law and the law of most other states on the issue of vehicular damages is that the victim is entitled to either the cost of repairing the vehicle or the fair market value of the car if it is a total loss.

Fair market value generally means the amount you could get for the car if you put an ad in the paper and tried to sell it. Kelly’s Blue Book private party value is a good way to estimate the fair market value. If what the insurance company offers is in the neighborhood of that value, it is probably accurate.

Unfortunately, most states (including Maryland) do not require payment of replacement value. This is a problem for two kinds of people. First are people who owe more on the vehicle than it is worth. They very well may end up making payments on a loan for a vehicle that has been totaled out. (GAP insurance solves this problem but if you are reading this and do not have GAP insurance, the horse is already out of the barn).

Second are people who have an older vehicle that is good basic transportation but has a low resale value. (It may be worth only $3,000 at a car lot to someone else, but you know you have a good reliable vehicle that you trust.) Often they are unable to recover enough to buy a similar replacement vehicle. This is an area where the law is not favorable to consumers who suffer property damage in an auto accident.

Do I have to use the insurance company’s repair shop?

No. You can have your vehicle repaired anywhere you choose. The insurance company will only pay what it thinks is the reasonable cost of repair, however. If the repairs run over price, or additional work is required, the shop will have to get approval from the insurance company to make sure they will be paid for their work. Often it is more convenient to use the insurance company’s approved repair shop because they have an easier time working through these kinds of issues with the carrier.

They are saying I will be liable for storage charges. Is this true?

You might. In Maryland, there is a duty to mitigate damages in property damage car accident cases. This means you can’t allow the vehicle to sit in storage, accruing storage fees, while you wait for the carrier to assume liability or to arrange for repairs. The best thing to do in this situation is to see if the insurer is willing to remove the vehicle from the tow lot to their storage facility, where it at least will not accrue more charges. Otherwise, it’s best to pay off the charges if you have the ability to do so.

Why won’t the insurance company send me a check until they talk to the car finance company?

If a vehicle is totaled out, the carrier will need to get the title transferred to them so the vehicle can be sold for salvage. In order to do this, the bank or finance company must release their interest in the vehicle. This means that the insurance company will need to find out the amount outstanding on the car loan, and pay off what is owed (if it is less than the fair market value of the vehicle). This means the finance company will be sent a check for their interest in the vehicle, and any money left over will go to you.

I got a rental car. How long can I stay in it?

You will normally be entitled to a rental until the repairs to the vehicle are completed or until the insurance company issues you a payment for the total loss of the vehicle. If there is a delay in this process, sometimes the insurer will agree to a reasonable extension of the rental to allow for it.

The vehicle in the accident was a truck, but they want me to take a compact as a rental. Can they do that?

No. The rental should be a vehicle comparable to the one it is intended to replace. This is often important when the driver needs a particular type of vehicle for work or business. The insurance company should at least provide a rental that is suitable for the same purpose as the car that was damaged. Now, you do not want to cut this too thin by demanding the exact same car on every level. Reasonableness should carry the day. But it should be the functional equivalent of the car that is damaged or totaled.

If I use my collision coverage, what about my deductible?

There are two ways to handle this. In the short term, you are out the deductible until it can be reimbursed. Either your own insurance company will recover the amount of the deductible for you from the other driver’s insurance once liability is resolved, or your attorney can include that with your damages and try to recover it as part of your case.

If I have an injury claim is my lawyer going to charge me to handle my property damage claim?

It depends on the lawyer, of course. Our law firm does not take a contingency fee for property damage or – unlike many other lawyers – the client’s personal injury protection (PIP) insurance. But, again, to be clear, our law firm does not handle property damage only cases. It is generally hard to find a vehicle damage claim attorney without a viable personal injury claim.

How do I pursue my own property damage claim in court?

Finding a lawyer to handle a car accident property damage claim can be challenging because such claims often involve relatively small amounts of money compared to personal injury claims. Lawyers typically work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they are paid a percentage of the settlement or judgment they secure for their clients.
In property damage cases, the potential recovery is honestly too low to justify the time and effort a lawyer would need to invest. That is the reality. Most car accident lawyers specialize in personal injury claims, which have higher stakes and more complex legal issues, making property damage claims less attractive to them. Consequently, many individuals end up handling property damage claims on their own or with minimal legal assistance.

If you can’t find a lawyer, there is a path to go at it alone.  It is a bit difficult because there are often local rules that require following procedural rules to make a claim. (In Maryland, for example, Maryland Courts and Judicial Proceedings Code Annotated § 10-105 controls property damage claims where the full claim is over $5,000.) So if you cannot find a lawyer for your property damage claim, you are going to have to figure out your state’s procedural rules.

Substantively, you must be prepared to back up any damages assertions you make. You should have your own estimate of the vehicle damage, or if it is a total loss, your own numbers establish the fair market value. Try the NADA guide as one measure of value. Nowadays many clients are concerned with the loss of resale value of an automobile as a result of having been in an accident.

Information services like CARFAX make accident information easy to obtain, and easy to factor into what one is willing to pay for a used car. Often insurance companies take the position that there has been no loss until the vehicle is actually sold for less. To prove this type of claim, make sure you are prepared with a lost value report, which can be obtained for a fee from a certified vehicle appraiser (who you may or may not have to bring to trial, depending upon the amount of the property damage claim and your state’s procedural rules.

Our car accident lawyers handle serious injury auto accident cases in the Baltimore-Washington area and have prevailed at trial in hundreds of car accident cases. Our car accident lawyers have also successfully settled thousands of cases for clients injured in automobile accidents, recovering millions of dollars in compensation for car accident victims by settlement or trial in 2008 alone. If you or someone you love has been injured or killed in a car accident, call us at 800-553-8082 or get a free consultation via the Internet.

More on Property Damage Claims

Dealing with the Insurance Company

More Information on Accident Claims

  • Maryland Accident Claims (get more information)
  • Truck Accident Claims (information specific to dealing with trucking defendants)
  • Can I Fire My Personal Injury Lawyer? (information on the decision of whether you terminate your current attorney)
  • Contacting Our Law Firm: Our lawyers handle only serious injury car accident claims. If you or someone you love has been seriously injured in a car or truck accident call 800-553-8082 or get a free online consultation.
Client Reviews
They quite literally worked as hard as if not harder than the doctors to save our lives. Terry Waldron
Ron helped me find a clear path that ended with my foot healing and a settlement that was much more than I hope for. Aaron Johnson
Hopefully I won't need it again but if I do, I have definitely found my lawyer for life and I would definitely recommend this office to anyone! Bridget Stevens
The last case I referred to them settled for $1.2 million. John Selinger
I am so grateful that I was lucky to pick Miller & Zois. Maggie Lauer
The entire team from the intake Samantha to the lawyer himself (Ron Miller) has been really approachable. Suzette Allen
The case settled and I got a lot more money than I expected. Ron even fought to reduce how much I owed in medical bills so I could get an even larger settlement. Nchedo Idahosa
Contact Information