Back Injury Settlements and verdicts
How much should you expect for your back injury settlement? People are uncomfortable asking that question but it really is -- and should be --- the primary question of anyone bringing an injury claim. Bringing a claim is not going to make improve your injury.
Value Varies Wildly by Injury
The value of back injury cases depends on the type of injury. At the top of the value chart is clearly spinal cord injuries. Assuming adequate insurance, these cases are typically valued in the millions. Next in line is disc injury cases. Herniated disc injury cases are typically valued at more than ruptured or bulging discusses but that is such a general rule that there are almost as many cases that fall in the exception as fall under the rule. Some herniated disc cases are million dollar cases and others are relatively minor injury cases that cause the victim little, if any, long term trouble. The settlement value of these types of back injury cases hinge on (1) whether their is any prior injury to that part of the back, (2) what the MRI/CT scan shows, and (3) what the physical symptoms are of the back injury and how the victim's life has been impacted by the injury.
At the bottom end of the scale for the amount you can expect for a back injury settlement is soft tissue back injuries that cannot be confirmed by any diagnostic testing. The value of these cases is going to depend on:
- the credibility of the plaintiff and the severity of the injury,
- whether there are preexisting back injuries,
- how significant the impact was, and
- which insurance company is involved. (You can find analysis of virtually every individual insurance company here.)
Obviously, the credibility of the plaintiff is critical in an personal injury case. It is as trite as saying that the key to winning a basketball game is putting the ball in the basket. But this common trope it is particularly true in back injury cases. Why? First, juries come at back injuries with a healthy skepticism. It is the cliche motor vehicle accident injury. Moreover, with back injuries, the extent of the injuries often don't line up with the radiological findings. I have medical experts tell me that the patient back is a absolute wreck but the patient is clinically do quite well. Conversely, I've seen small disc herniations that I'm 100% convinced have caused an injury that causes pain to the victim 24 hour a day. So, if an out-of-court settlement cannot be reached, the plaintiff definitely needs to carry the ball at her deposition, and, if necessary, at trial.
Ultimately, as you can see, there are a lot of variables at play in valuing these cases. There is no calculator or formula that is going to give you the answer of how much money you can expect in a settlement.
Pre-Existing Injuries and Back Injury Settlements
More Case Value Information
The toughest back injury cases involve preexisting injuries. But favorable settlements and jury verdicts can be had in many cases with preexisting injuries. Ultimately, the law is that your compensation should be the difference between how you felt before the crash and how you felt after, assuming the accident caused the change in the condition.
The key is having an attorney and a doctor who can articulate the difference between your problems and treatment before the accident and your current condition. If the crash trauma did not cause a change in your condition, your chances of getting a favorable settlement are slim. If, on the other hand, there is a clear change in your injuries from before the wreck, the likelihood of a good settlement is quite high.
That said, these are the types of cases insurance companies want to fight. Most of our cases settle before we ever file a lawsuit. Is this true with our back injury case with pre-existing injuries? No. We usually have to slug it out with them for at least a while to get fair value or better.
We fight to get our clients who have suffered serious back injuries the value they deserve: either by settlement or at trial. Call us to discuss your case at 800-553-8082 or get a free on-line consultation.