2434 W. BELVEDERE AVENUE
BALTIMORE, MD 21215
- Located in Baltimore City, Maryland
- Nonprofit corporation owned by LifeBridge
- Certified beds: 210
- Known Lawsuits Against This Facility
- Kolodner v. Levindale Hebrew (negligent - improper size catheter - and assault and battery) (2009)
- James v. Levindale Hebrew (injury while in rehab - case settled) (2007)
- Rozzell v. Levindale Hebrew (wrongful death from bedsore on decedent's heel) (2004)
- Barksdale v. Levindale Hebrew (wrongful death from Stage IV bedsore - Levindale settled for just $10,000) (2004)
- Troia v. Levindale Hebrew (fall out of Geri chair case - case settled) (2003)
- Mizrach v. Levindale Hebrew (case settled) (2002)
Levindale Hebrew Geriatric Center and Hospital is a nonprofit nursing home near Mt. Washington that has 210 certified beds and provides respite, dementia, respiratory, and hospice care, in addition to skilled long-term care. Since 1967 it has been part of LifeBridge Health, a Baltimore-based health care organization that operates five hospitals in the area.
With a total count of 196 residents at the last official count, Levindale is much large (population-wise) than the average for Maryland nursing homes (107.5 residents), and more than twice as large as the national average (86.2 residents). That's a seriously big number of people for whom to care - especially considering that many or most of them probably have special needs and require a lot of attention. (And this facility isn't even filled to capacity.)
Consider, then, that this facility's most recent Medicare rating for staffing was five stars - the top score. (Medicare, being very numbers-oriented, rates nurse staffing based on the amount of time nurses spend with residents.) So Levindale gets an "A" for effort. Staffing - assuming you are not blithely hiring the very worst -- really is the hustle of nursing home care. It is an economic commitment to being good.
Unfortunately, that top rating for staffing doesn't square with Levindale's two-star rating (below average) for quality measures - which are numerical gauges of the quality of the care residents receive.
There are also a very large number of lawsuits against this single facility which is always going to attract the attention of nursing home lawyers. We have not found recent lawsuits. We do not know if means this facility is being sued less frequently or whether the reporting was just better years ago. But clearly this facility has had some problems that led to lawsuits. A single lawsuit proves very little but this many lawsuits, even for such a large facility, raises eyebrows.Levindale Competitors
Before we dig deep into Levindale's nursing home, let's look at the facility's competition. The immediate area really has the best and worst of nursing homes in Baltimore.
- Blue Point Healthcare Center: Located just a block or so from Levindale in Baltimore, this CommuniCare facility got a piddling 1-star Medicare rating overall (versus Levindale's 3 stars) and another piddling 1 star for staffing (versus Levindale's five stars). But Blue Point did outscore Levindale on quality measures (4 stars to 2 stars).
- Northwest Healthcare Center: Here is another unit of CommuniCare, located only about a third of a mile from its sister facility, Blue Point, in Baltimore. Northwest equals or surpasses Blue Point in all four main Medicare rating categories, which makes one wonder whether the parent company is paying attention: why should one of its units so outperform another? But these sibling organizations do have something in common: inferior to Levindale in three main Medicare categories (including the overall rating), both of them outscored Levindale (4 stars to 2 stars) on quality measures.
- Autumn Lake Healthcare at Alice Manor: This Baltimore facility comes in second to Levindale for its overall Medicare rating (2 stars to 3 stars) and its staffing score, although it edges Levindale (3 stars to 2 stars) on quality measures.
- ManorCare Health Services - Roland Park: Both this Baltimore facility and Levindale got 3-star average ratings from Medicare overall. But whereas Levindale was much better on staffing (5 stars to 3 stars), ManorCare easily won on quality measures (5 stars to 2 stars).
- Augsburg Lutheran Home: This Baltimore facility's main Medicare scores were identical with those of its nearby neighbor ManorCare, so these two practically next-door neighbors line up in similar fashion against Levindale.
- Brinton Woods Health and Rehabilitation Center at Arlington West: Brinton Woods and Levindale trade shots over staffing (Levindale wins) and quality measures (Brinton Woods wins), but this Baltimore facility got only two stars from Medicare overall, versus Levindale's three stars.
- Lochearn Nursing Home, LLC: Levindale has some reason to fear competition from this other Baltimore facility, which much outscores it on the Medicare ratings: 5 stars to 3 stars overall; 5 stars to 2 stars for quality measures; and average or above-average ratings for the other two main Medicare metrics.
- Crawford Retreat: Located just over a mile from Levindale, this Baltimore facility had main Medicare scores almost comparable with those of Lochearn, and it beats Levindale's scores by almost as much.
- Bridgepark Healthcare Center: Bridgepark Healthcare is mostly little competition for Levindale - with an abysmal 1-star Medicare rating overall (versus Levindale's three stars). This Baltimore facility also under ranks Levindale for their health inspections and staffing. Somehow Bridgepark beat Levindale, four stars to 2 stars, on quality measures.
- Roland Park Place: Sounding a bit like a spot on the board of "Monopoly," Roland Park Place just missed getting "perfect" 5-star ratings across the board from Medicare (it got four stars, instead of 5 stars, for its health inspection). Very few facilities anywhere (including Levindale) can compete with scores like these.
- Keswick Multi-Care Center: This Baltimore facility gets Medicare's overall below-average rating of 2 stars (versus an overall average rating for Levindale). The difference is probably Keswick's rock-bottom 1-star rating for its health inspection (for which Levindale got two stars).
- Milford Manor Nursing Home: Milford Manor received abysmal (1-star) scores in three of four main Medicare categories. Levindale got no less than two stars for anything, and even beat Milford Manor in the latter's best category of staffing (5 stars to 4 stars).
In its last standard Medicare inspection (February 2016), Levindale received an overall rating of 3 stars - average. That cumulative rating reflects the fact that the facility's 5-star rating for staffing was counterweighed by 2-star ratings both for quality measures and its health inspection.
The health inspection found a total of 16 deficiencies -- significantly more than the Maryland state average of 11.4, and over twice the U.S. average of 7.1 deficiencies. Levindale had deficiencies in seven of eight measured categories, including five with respect to quality care, and one for mistreatment. It did far better on its fire safety inspection: just a single deficiency, versus the Maryland and national averages of 4.0 and 3.4, respectively.
Levindale had a Medicare complaint inspection in April, 2016, with respect to two isolated incidents. In this instance, a resident, as discovered by a family member) had a bruised arm and a bloodied mouth. A private aide to the resident was suspected of foul play. What a mess. Medicare cited Levindale for not doing a thorough pre-screening of the aide. Whether this is true or hindsight analysis is anyone's guess. Of course, any abuse of residents is a serious matter.
In the second case, a resident's family member requested that staffers give the resident a certain medication that the facility did not have in stock (but subsequently did attempt to obtain). Medicare said that the facility should have consulted the prescribing physician about the issue.Lots of Nurse Time
Now we turn to this facility's core strength: its 5-star nursing staff.
One Medicare stat tallies the total amount of nursing time (by all nurses) per resident per day. Levindale was much superior on this score, giving residents a total of 2 hours and 44 minutes of daily nursing time, versus the Maryland state average of 1 hour and 51 minutes, and the national average of 1 hour and 42 minutes. That's about an hour more at Levindale than the state and national averages.
Levindale got a 5-star rating for its RN staffing in particular. RN daily time per resident here was 1 hour and 15 minutes, versus 59 minutes for the Maryland state average, and 50 minutes for the U.S. average.
This facility also beat the Maryland and U.S. averages -- by a lot -- on time spent by LPNs and LVNs (licensed practical nurses, licensed vocational nurses) and certified nursing assistants. Levindale residents got more than half an hour more per day, in both of these nursing categories, than the Maryland and U.S. averages. It also was above average in time provided by physical therapists.Lost in Translation
Given all that nursing time, the question then becomes: how did this facility score below average (2 stars) on quality measures?
This facility could not have received that low 2-star rating based on the stats for its short-stay residents, because its stats were exceptionally good. Levindale beat the Maryland and U.S. averages in eight of nine measured categories.
Notably, this facility's short-stay residents were only a third as likely as the state and national averages to have problems with pressure sores and they were less than half as likely as the state and national norms to report having serious pain. The rate of successful discharges also was higher here than the Maryland and U.S. averages.
The only metric in which Levindale was a bit below average was on improving short-term residents' functionality - a somewhat dubious statistic because it may not take into account how many residents needed to improve their functionality. If the Medicare score were based on its short-stay residents alone, this facility would seem to deserve at least a 4-star rating on quality measures.
This facility's quality measure scores for long-term residents definitely were less good than for short-stayers, although it also stands to reason that long-stay residents would have more serious health issues.
For the 15 measured categories related to long-stay residents, Levindale beat the Maryland and U.S. averages in seven categories - and sometimes by a lot. The percentage of its long-stay residents who reported having serious pain was an impressively minuscule 0.7 percent - about one-tenth the Maryland and U.S. averages of 6.0 percent and 7.8 percent, respectively. The depression rate among long-stay residents here was only 2.2 percent - less than half the state and national averages - and Levindale also dispensed fewer antianxiety and antipsychotic meds.
On the minus side, long-stay residents here were almost twice as likely as the Maryland and U.S. averages to acquire urinary tract infections, and they were twice as likely to be subjected to ongoing catheterization. And they were about three times as likely as the state or national averages to be subjected to physical restraints. In five other measured categories, Levindale's stats for long-stay residents were somewhat below the state and U.S. averages, though not to as sharp an extent.Lawsuits Against Levindale Hebrew
There have been a number of lawsuits filed against Levindale as you saw in the introduction. It is hard to get to find out the resolutions to these cases but many were reported to have reached a settlement. Cases against this nursing home have been typically defended by Goodell, DeVries, Leech & Dann.
- January 11, 2019: Autry v. Levindale Geriatric Center: A wrongful death lawsuit is filed against the nursing home after a patient dies from significant head trauma after a fall. There had already been a list of documented falls for that patient up until the fatal one.
Baltimore Nursing Home Lawyer
Have you or someone you love suffered harm (or killed) in a Baltimore nursing home or assisted living facility? Call our nursing home lawyer at Miller & Zois today at 800-553-8082 or get a FREE no obligation case review.More Information
- This nursing home has been around for a very long time
- Look at nursing home lawsuits filed in Maryland in 2016. You will see common themes: falls, bedsores (and Genesis as a defendant)
- How much money can you expect in a nursing home cases? It is a fair question. Get case value information and learn how nursing home claims are valued for settlement
- We breakdown all of the Maryland nursing homes like we did for Levindale Hebrew
- Call our Baltimore nursing home attorneys right now at 1.800.553.8082 or get a FREE online case review. We can help you.