New Appellate First

The Hon. Michele Hotten was sworn in yesterday as a judge on the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland. According to news accounts, this makes her the first black female appellate judge in Maryland. Officially, anyway. I know for a fact that women of color have sat on appellate panels in Maryland by special assignment, because I have argued in front of them.

I wonder how long these kinds of firsts will continue to be relevant. I have appeared before Judge Hotten many times during her time as a circuit court judge, and I can’t say that I have ever really noticed her ethnicity. Maybe to the general public, this is significant, but for me it’s not an issue. There are lots of black judges in Maryland. Unsurprisingly, they tend to be a lot like the white ones. Some are great, others not so much.

I guess every time a “first” like this is crossed off the list, we as a society take one more step toward race becoming irrelevant. That is probably a good thing.